Impatience of Youth VS Mirror of broken images

[Electrified]

Impatience of Youth 321- Mastery and 1605 Str for 20 seconds

or

Mirror of broken images 321 - Mastery and 400 resistance against fire, frost, arcane and nature damge

Which of these is the best tanking trinket? I'm consider both due to the parry and dmg boost you gain on the Impatience of youth... and then the resistance to magic dmg on the other trinket for 10 seconds.

The reason I'm asking is that a irl friends told me that the moonwell trinket isn't that great due to you having to be static within it to gain the dodge, and the stamina is overrated.

What is your experience on this matter?

Greetings from the Paladin side of the Force. (since I can't decide which side to join)

[Dar]

There are only 2 fights in FL where you can use the moonwell, but having the trinket on those fights is a real bonus where your healers will be grateful for. (if you are wondering: Baleroc, static for tanks, healers and ranged dps, and Beth'tilac, static once you have your tanking target in place)

For the others, I'd go for the Mirror, firelands has a lot of Fire and since we are going to DW himself in the next patch, you will burn a lot more

and when I say a lot more, I mean a lot more, like daily blink says it:

[Electrified]

went for the mirror

Thanks!